EDDIEWONG

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

So, I guess the question would clearly be, “which 1/6th Dark Knight Batman figure is the better one between Medicoms’ and Hot Toys’?”


UPDATE 2009.05.15
I’m selling the Medicom TDK Batman. Check it out ‘here‘.

 
Well, the answer is simple: I’m not sure how they can be compared, seriously.

If you asked, “which figure closely resembles the onscreen Batman?”
I’d answer Medicoms’ is more screen accurate.

If you asked, “which figure is more life-like?”
I’d answer Hot Toys’ is more life-like.

If you asked, “which is more like a toy?”
I’d answer Medicoms’ looks more like a toy.

If you asked, “which is better in build quality?”
I’d answer Hot Toys is better built.

See? There really is no definitive answer. It really depends on what you’re after.

Like said, both are fantastic figures. Both cost approx. ¥20,000 each. Both stand at over 12-inches tall. Both have their good and bad points.

That is all I can say. Below are some side-by-side comparison photos. Which one looks better to you?

 
Medicom Dark Knight Batman

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight

 
UPDATE 2009.05.15
I’m selling the Medicom TDK Batman. Check it out ‘here‘.

 
Medicom VS Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Hot Toys, right is Medicom

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Hot Toys, right is Medicom

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Hot Toys, right is Medicom

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Left is Medicom, right is Hot Toys

 
UPDATE 2009.05.15
I’m selling the Medicom TDK Batman. Check it out ‘here‘.

 
See also:

Medicom Dark Knight VS Hot Toys Dark Knight
Medicom Dark Knight Batman GET!
MMS DX Dark Knight Batman?
OMFG! Hot Toys MMX DX Joker!
Hot Toys Joker version 4?
Police Officer Joker is MMS DX series
Keeping the HT Harvey Dent
Hot Toys Harvey Dent/Two-Face get!
Hot Toys hints at 1/6th Joker version 3
Dark Knight figures like you’ve never seen before
My Bank Robber Joker headsculpt
My Hot Toys Batman figures
Hot Toys 1/6th Two-Face/Harvey Dent
Hot Toys 1/6th The Dark Knight Batman
Hot Toys 1/6th Joker – Bank Robber
ITTS: Hot Toys 1/6th The Dark Knight Batman
ITTS: Hot Toys 1/6th Original suit Batman
ITTS: Hot Toys 1/6th Joker
ITTS: Hot Toys 1/6th Batmobile
ITTS: Hot Toys 1/6th Batpod
Hot Toys 1/6th Original suit Batman
Hot Toys 1/6th Joker
Hot Toys 1/6th Iron-Man
Hot Toys Booth

12 comments
ad_line_bottom.gif



ad_line_bottom.gif





ad_line_bottom.gif

12 Comments so far

    cavell 2009 May 5th 11:21 pm

    Both beautiful :( But I think I’m just going to stick with my Hot Toys one! Don’t even know if I will get the DX version if it is next

    retaane 2009 May 6th 12:41 am

    only one can be posed in gliding mode Medicom click link below
    http://img80.imageshack.us/img80/5416/img1518b.jpg

    PolishTank 2009 May 6th 5:12 am

    Well, obviously Hot Toys gets a lot of praise for their figure, but to be honest: I like the Medicom version much better. The face is 100% Bale on the Medicom figure, on the Hot Toys version it looks nothing like Bale. The chest on the Hot Toys version is waaay to big. It looks awful to me. I guess in terms of build quality the Hot Toys one is better, but onscreen-likeness is so much more important to me and the way I see it, Medicom beats Hot Toys in this category by far. The only thing I don’t like about the Medicom figure is the sculpting of back of the head, it looks a bit odd. But the face, the body proportions and the overall likeness is so much more like Batman from TDK.

    Edward 2009 May 6th 7:50 am

    your nuts if you think HT Batman is better than Com Bats. The only thing better about HT batman is the belt and the mini bomb

    Jinwolves 2009 May 6th 8:32 am

    Wow!!! Medicom is amazing…. hot toys lose the battle this time

    BatsUSA 2009 May 7th 8:48 am

    I have both Medicom and Hot Toys DK and Eddie is right on – positives and negatives with both.

    Overall – the Hot Toys figure is more solid – shows better craftsmanship – and the small details are right (for small detail example, which may be a bit picky, Batman’s glove “fins” on HT version are spot on – with spaces at the tips like in the movie). The shoulder protectors are also glued on in the Medicom version, which allows for greater movement, but can be a bit odd looking in some poses. Medicom is less solid but it does get the “movie look” more closely than HT – colors, thinner chest and arms, etc. The Medicom version is more accurate in the costume – especially the pants and chest area. But, while the hot toys figure has rubber pants and is solidly built around the legs, the Medicom version has cotton stuffed in the pants to give them shape…which impacts movement and makes the figure feel cheaper in my opinion. The hands on the Medicom version do change out easier than the HT version, again in my opinion. Hot toys gets a plus for accessories – an additional Bale head. Medicom is just the figure with the grapel gun and two batarangs.

    As Eddie says, choosing which one to buy just depends on what you’re looking for. I don’t think you can lose with either.

    eddie 2009 May 8th 1:15 am

    @ cavell
    I’m all for an improved Bats from HT under the DX brand

    @ retaane
    Hmmm…. I’m not sure this is even an argument for getting the Medicom

    @ PolishTank
    Yes, Medicom does resemble the onscreen Batman more than HT does

    @ Edward
    You know, those who do not own both figures but praises only the one they own… they’re the type that are nuts. You don’t happen to be one of these nuts who own only one figure do you, kid?

    @ Jinwolves
    HT has definitely lost in terms of screen-accuracy but things like build quality, life-like, etc., HT is better

    @ BatsUSA
    Right on

    manuel alexander 2009 June 5th 9:32 am

    hello my friends, I see that the hot toys are behind much of Medicom, Medicom is the most detailed layer Medicom is much better because it stays in various positions, the face of the hot looks of a toy cat, hhhh . Medicom is the much better ..

    Sadi M. Pekerol III 2009 June 8th 3:36 am

    Hey Eddie Long Time my friend How are you?

    Tell me eddie on the Medicom RAH 424 TDK Batman what is a concern for me is the articulation on it, Is it durable all over? what have they changed on the internal body chassis? DID THEY GET THE WAIST AREA RESOLVED OFFERING THE SAME waste articulation as the HT TT? thanks for the info.

    eddie 2009 June 8th 7:20 pm

    Hey Sadi

    I’m good. And yourself?
    I’ve seen you asking this question on MediBoard on a good few forum pages. I guess you got no reply because I doubt anyone knows how to answer your questions, which are rather tricky and anal. Anyway, I’ll try:

    “articulation on it, Is it durable all over?”
    Erm… it all seems as durable as HT body. But of course, the more you bend and twist the limbs, the more loose they will become over time.

    “what have they changed on the internal body chassis? ”
    No idea, man. This is my first Medicom RAH figure. Besides, there is no way you can remove the batsuit to check without ripping it apart.

    “DID THEY GET THE WAIST AREA RESOLVED OFFERING THE SAME waste articulation as the HT TT?”
    Again, no idea. You should keep in mind, both HT and Medicom Batman have a sealed rubber suit which will basically restrict any kind of movement on the waist, legs, arms, etc.

    Edison Capili 2009 June 11th 9:13 pm

    Head sculpt and lifelike appearance i will give my 2 cents to Hottoys when it comes to The Dark Knight thing, just to these two figures in comparison. Since Medicom has lots of great figures also to boast for. At the end of the day these two manufacturers Hottoys and Medicom are surely both winners.

    Mike C 2009 July 10th 5:57 am

    Hey Eddie,

    Is the Medi Bats still for sale? I would like to buy it but don’t know the proper avenue for purchasing it.

    Thanks
    Mike (mkcc30 on ebay and on several boards including SS Freaks)

Leave a reply

Page 1 of 0